Trapped on a Moon (Star Wars #57 Comic Review)

Writer- Kieron Gillan

Artist- Angel Unzueta

Colorist- Guru-eFX

Letterer- VC’s Clayton Cowles

Cover Artist- Jamal Campbell

Variant cover artist- John Tyler Christopher

After escaping from Imperial forces our intrepid heroes, Han, Luke and Leia, find themselves on an unfamiliar moon.  They are rescued from some savage wildlife by the people who have made this moon their home.

Summary:

We start the issue with Han, Luke, and Leia sitting in a really nice looking garden waiting for the head of the community to come talk to them.  Han seems to be ambivalent about the whole thing, but Luke and Leia are pretty desperate to get back to the rebels.  They are naturally suspicious of the man in charge and spend most of the issue trying to feel him out. Meanwhile Han is off being comic relief.

Luke is the one who ends up spending the most time with the leader, a man named Markona.   He also appears to be the most suspicious of Markona’s motivations.  He’s determined to get himself and his friends off the moon and away from Markona and his people, but getting off the moon won’t be easy.

Thoughts:

There is a conversation between Luke and Markona that involved a line that seemed a little odd to me in the grand picture that is the Star Wars Franchise.   In fact I ended up spending a lot of time overanalyzing that line.  Which was pointless, because the line I fixated on is clearly not going to be the focus of this narrative.  The focus of this narrative seems to be that actions speak louder than words.

Anything Markona says could be a lie.  Even if he gave Luke the answers he wanted to hear it would be entirely possible that they would just be falsehoods he using to appease Luke.  The only way that Luke is going to get a better understanding of Markona’s character is observing his actions.

Other than that though this particular issue feels like filler.  It’s a transition from one part of the overall narrative to another and is honestly a little dull because of that.  There is some intrigue to try and hook us into coming back for the next issue, but other than that this feels like a lot of exposition.  With that out of the way through the next issue should be more engaging and we should get more of those actions we’re meant to be judging Markona on.

I’m honestly okay with the content of an issue being set up for a bigger storyline in an upcoming issue.  It can be boring, but the payoff could be amazing.  The biggest problem I have with this issue is actually the art.  As we all know, Star Wars started as a live-action film series, meaning that Han, Luke, and Leia were originally portrayed by real-life people.  The art in this book tries really hard to make the characters look like the original actors, which is actually kind of off-putting.  For me, this crosses into the uncanny valley.  They did a great job capturing the likenesses of the actors, but it’s off-putting.

The non-film characters look better, but there is still something… off about them.

The backgrounds and scenes are great though.  The environments, the creatures, and all of the science fiction elements all look amazing both on their own and together.  It’s just the human characters that feel out of place.  Which is frustrating because the people are the focus of the story, not the setting.

Share to

Sarah Bieniek

Sarah Bieniek

I live in the desert and spend a lot of time reading comics and any science fiction I can get my hands on.
Summary
Honestly, I was pretty bored while reading this. I can see the potential for it to be a great read once we get deep into the story, but the setup isn’t all that exciting or engaging. The art was also pretty frustrating. In some aspects I really loved it, but in others I found it off putting and it made me disengage from the story.
Good
  • Nice set up for future storylines
  • Great environments
Bad
  • A little slow and dull
  • Off putting character art
6.5
Fair
Written by
I live in the desert and spend a lot of time reading comics and any science fiction I can get my hands on.

Have your say!

0 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>